|
Post by outcast5 on Dec 22, 2010 5:07:22 GMT -5
Perhaps not the best way to win/lose i can agree. But accept the consequences of your actions. It is very clear in the rules regarding this issue so there should be no room to argue. Let us move on to playoffs and redeem yourself if you feel as though you wrongly lost.
|
|
|
Post by chefgravi on Dec 22, 2010 7:08:57 GMT -5
I agree we should be punished, the rules are rules and all fleets are expected to abide by them. But in hindsight, the peanlization should be marked in a different way. I do not think the opposing team(GoD in this case) should be rewarded a win. They did not deserve a win, and were just as much at fault as we were in that match. Our first offense had nothing to do with this match, so it should have nothing to do with the result of the match. I think that the fleet with the second offense (Red Sky in this case) should have a point deducted after the result. Leaving Red Sky with 3 wins, but 2 points on the table.
I understand if the ruling stays as is, but I think this method should be taken into consideration for future league seasons. As giving Wins to fleets who did not earn them is not fair to the other participating fleets. For arguements sake, say Vets had broken a rule this week, would you have then given EoM a win? Then you'd have to take Imperium into consideration (Vets first offense,) Vets infringed on the rules against them, but they get no win? I think its just in the best interest of all Fleets in FL to implement a Point deduction system, instead of rewarding fleets who did nothing to deserve wins.
Regardless, we should not have had the T5 scout, it was a terrible mistake and we deserve to be punished.
|
|
|
Post by marko on Dec 22, 2010 15:21:13 GMT -5
chef deducting 1 point is the same thing as a loss a loss for both teams.
you win but you got a second warning to you get 1 point for the win and you loss that point for the warning. you will still be ranked the same only thing is you are taking away a point from a team that didnt break a rule twice.
i agree winning on a technicality isnt the best win but rules are rules and having doc change a rules in anyones favor you would get more flank then him not changing it. also at the start of the next season make a suggestion for a rules change mid season rule changes that big will throw off the whole season.
also you got into the play offs so does it matter?
|
|
kiels
New Member
Posts: 15
|
Post by kiels on Dec 22, 2010 15:37:01 GMT -5
3 points for clean win, 2 points for first warning wing, 1 point for second warning win. DQ for 3 warning
|
|
|
Post by docryan13 on Dec 23, 2010 0:38:51 GMT -5
PM sent to Chef regarding the RS and GoD match.
|
|
|
Post by devildog8 on Dec 24, 2010 19:20:12 GMT -5
just going to say that the rules clearly state 2 warnings = loss, not even sure why a debate is needed at this point, all rule change suggestions should be brought up before next season, not at the end
|
|